The festive 50 is dead … long live the festive 50!
Now I do still remember those nights with fingers paused over the cassette deck, with the tuner tuned to the dulcet tones of John Peel in the lead up to Xmas, clicking the record button on as he perambulated through his Festive 50.
We were all safe, of course, in the knowledge that each year about 25 of John Peel’s Festive 50 would include the hallmark of Mr Mark E Smith and The Fall!
But come early January, I would be able to profusely debate the highs and lows of the years sonic adventures and their placings on Mr Peel’s chart; and with the additional bonus of getting to hear some of the unexpected and come to love them too. Of course we no longer have that pleasure and somehow, those other DJ’s don’t quite have …the knack.
So, where does the ear of the music lover go to be able to argue the toss with some other fools opinion over the best of the year?
The NME Top 50? I think not.
I’m too old and I know that the Last Shadow Puppets will be there at number 1 with Crystal Castles not far behind. You can’t go for the dance rags… , well lets face it, there isn’t enough good dance music to fill a top 10 at the moment (honestly – do you think so? send us the proof).
The Mojo Top 50?
The Mojo top 50 will have the Last Shadow Puppets at number 1 again. And although I’m too old for the NME , I’m not THAT old that I’d want to put a Joni Mitchell reissue in the top 10.
For me, this leaves only one source for annual music quarrelling– the Rough Trade Top 50 albums of the year.
Oh I know the top 10 will be infested with neurotic white men – but have you heard the Bon Iver ‘For Emma’? It’s a heartbreaker and can we argue with Fleet foxes at number 2?
I defy anyone to dislike the Vampire Weekend album ( well, apart from my 10 year old headbanger of a son – but then he loves My Chemical Romance!)
We also have the El Guincho and Benga albums crashing the top 10, both an absolute treat and radically different to the usual guitar led business…things get yet more interesting later in the 50, with Earth and Dengue Fever popping up.
My big surprises? What on earth are Foals doing in the last 10? Surely they managed to be a significant part of the move away from the usual English guitar sound, heralding in the opportunity to play with sound and structure a little more; and of course, everyone loves the MGMT album but don’t want everyone else to know.
I’d also be wanting some inclusions – Kills ‘Midnight Boom’, surely the best post pub hip wriggler to slam on; No Age ‘Nouns’? No Deerhunter ‘Microcastles’?
The Rough Trade 50 best albums of 2008 list acts as a point of argument, a prompt to albums you’ve forgotten came out, a chance to reconsider your previous ill founded opinion and your chance to discover musical pastures new….now, where’s my download of the Earth album? Anything called ‘The Bees Made Honey in the Lions Skull’ has just got to be worth a listen or two……
Here’s my Top 10 Best Albums of the Year 2008
Bon Iver ‘For Emma’
Flying Lotus ‘Los Angeles’
The Kills ‘Midnight Boom’
El Benga ‘Diary of an Afro Warrior’
White Denim ’ Workout Holiday’
Matthew Dear ’Body Language Mix 7’
Gang Gang Dance ‘ Saint Dymphna’
No Age ‘Nouns’
Vampire Weekend ‘S/T’
That’s my best albums of 2008. What’s yours?